Investing using the rearview mirror

If we could invest by simply looking at what has done well in the recent past – and by that we mean the past few years, not just months – then life would be so much simpler. Unfortunately, rearview mirror investing is not the best way to build portfolios for the future, which is where our spending and intergenerational transfers will take place.

If we take the past three years or so, looking through our rearview lens, we certainly would not want to have too large a position in the UK or emerging equity markets or global commercial property or value or smaller company stocks, which fared poorly on a relative rather than an absolute basis, compared to large companies in overseas developed markets. The latter in turn lagged the broad US market, which in turn lagged the growth-oriented stocks, particularly technology companies. In an extreme rear-view mirror scenario, a hindsight investor would invest heavily in US growth stocks going forward. That would be a very concentrated bet and would ignore the fact that all future growth expectations are captured in today’s prices. These companies need to perform better than these expectations for prices to rise.

The chart below illustrates the rearview investing conundrum by looking at market returns by decade. What is plainly evident is that each part of a sensible portfolio waxes and wanes over time. At the end of the 2000s the rearview mirror investor would have avoided the broad US and World developed markets, yet in the 2010s they were exceptionally strong performers and emerging markets and value stocks suffered relative to the US and the UK was a laggard. To want to place all your investment eggs in one basket – and in particular the one that has just performed best – seems a little naïve. No-one knows what the 2020s will bring and diversification is a key tool in mitigating the unknown.

As such, we take a highly diversified approach when building our clients’ portfolios. We also believe that limited exposure to more risky parts of the markets, including companies in emerging countries, smaller companies, and value (relatively cheaper) companies provide the opportunity – although never the guarantee – or delivering returns a little above the broad markets. It can take some time for them to shine through. If an extra return were guaranteed, there would be no risk to picking up the return (and it would not exist).

In an environment when cash delivers a negative return after inflation, and the expected returns for both bonds and equities are reduced as a consequence, these incremental returns are not to be sniffed at. They happen to be all the things that have not done as well (in a relative sense) in the past few years, although they have still delivered strong absolute returns to investors. Rearview investors would avoid them to their detriment. More fool them.

Do not look back and wish you had owned a different portfolio but take comfort from the fact that your highly diversified and soundly structured portfolio gives you every chance of a successful outcome in an unknown, forward looking world.


About the Author

Jon is a highly qualified and experienced Chartered Financial Planner and Certified Financial Planner with over 27 years’ experience. He loves working with clients who are passionate about getting the most out of life and feels his job is to support them living life to the fullest. Read more from Jonathan...
This article is distributed for educational purposes and should not be considered investment advice or an offer of any product for sale. This article contains the opinions of the author but not necessarily the Firm and does not represent a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed. Past performance is not indicative of future results and no representation is made that the stated results will be replicated.
Dom, your expert advice and management of our modest resources has made our retirement more comfortable than we ever imagined it would be. D & Y P (Suffolk)

Expert Opinion…

5 staycation destinations for an early break in 2021

Jonathan, December 11th, 2020

With the four nations split in their response to the coronavirus pandemic, different tier systems, lockdowns, and local restrictions could apply across the UK at the start of the new year. But with vaccine rollouts starting and the potential for more areas to come out of the higher tiers as the overall […]

Read More
Your guide to the art of perfect sleep

Dominic, December 11th, 2020

Sleep plays an important role in our physical and mental health. A good night’s rest can heal and repair our bodies and consolidate memories. Prolonged bad sleep, on the other hand, is linked to high blood pressure and problems such as anxiety and depression. A good night’s sleep is crucial but not […]

Read More
5 tips for a better work-life balance as a business owner

Dominic, December 11th, 2020

Striking a positive work-life balance as a business owner has been difficult this year, but it is vital for physical and mental health. Here are five tips to help.

Read More
T: 01993 772467      E:

Expert Wealth Management, West Wing, The Old Dairy, High Cogges Farm, Witney, Oxfordshire, OX29 6UN

Your Protection: In the unlikely event of your ever having a complaint which we have not been able to resolve amicably, you have recourse to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS). This is an independent body which will investigate complaints at no cost to you.  The FOS website is

Join The Expert Wealth Family As A Paraplanner >